Marwa’s family ends Dresden Orchestra’s performances in Egypt

Mohamed Abdel Salam
  29 October 2009 in Art, Culture, News

Marwa_el-sherbini._Funeral_meeting_dresden_-_germanyCAIRO: The Cairo Opera House and the German Embassy in Cairo announced their decision to postpone two concerts, which were scheduled to feature a leading German orchestra later this week, after it came under public pressure and security concerns. The cancellation comes as Marwa el-Sherbini’s family – the Egyptian woman murdered in a Dresden, Germany, courtroom in July – pressured the Egyptian culture ministry to bar the German orchestra from playing in the country.

The Dresden Orchestra was due to perform in Cairo and Alexandria, Egypt’s largest two cities, to ‘promote tolerance’ three months after the slaying of the Egyptian woman in Dresden by a German-Russian man after he had been convicted of hate speech and required to pay a fine of some 700 euros. The Dresden Orchestra, which is the oldest orchestra in Europe, had hoped their performance would help heal wounds between Egypt and German.

It was established over 500 years ago.

Egypt’s Minister of Culture Farouk Hosni said the “postponement of [the] German Dresden orchestral concerts in Sayyed Darwish Theater in Alexandria and the Grand Theater in Egyptian Opera House was built on the agreement and consent of the Egyptian Opera House and Dresden Orchestra troupe.”

He added that the reasons for the postponement came on the grounds that “the German conductor was going to speak on the relationship between the Egyptian and German people and confirm that this crime [the killing of Sherbini] should not affect the relationship between the two countries and peoples, and requested a moment of silence on the soul.”

Hosni continued, saying that “but at the insistence of the family of Marwa over the refusal of the concert, especially with the start of the trial in Dresden, prompted an agreement on the delay taking into account the feelings of the family. He added that “we must distinguish between a crime that claimed the life of Marwa and between the relationship with the German people and their arts.”

Sources from the Egyptian Ministry of Culture said that the ministry sent a request late last week asking for the postponement of the orchestra’s concerts for fear of clashes because of the anger in the street raised by the murder of Marwa. This revelation comes despite the ministry’s continued claims last week that the concerts would go forward without a glitch.

Reports suggested that Marwa’s family opposed the creation of such cultural events, especially despite the German Embassy arguing in an earlier statement that the celebration “comes to signal that the death of their daughter is an individual case [and] does not represent the German people and that relations between Egyptians and Germans are more important than this incident.”

The Egyptian Opera House and Dresden Orchestra had agreed last year on the performances and Herbert Mitscht was scheduled to lead the musicians in the concerts scheduled for October 31 and November 2.

Sherbini’s family appealed to Hosni to cancel the performances “out of respect of our feelings and those of the Egyptian people.” He acquiesced.

Sherbini, a 31-year-old pharmacist, was stabbed 18 times by Alex Wiens, a Russian-born German in a courthouse where a legal dispute between them was being heard. Sherbini, a mother of a three-year-old child, was pregnant when she was killed, according to her family.

(see also “Marwa el-Sherbini trial to begin, Arabs watch and wait”)

The murder outraged Muslims inside and outside Egypt, and raised fears of a new wave of anti-Islamism in the West. The victim was dubbed “the martyr of the hijab.” The killer also stabbed Sherbini’s husband as German police reacted slowly, shooting Sherbini’s husband in the leg, allegedly having mistaken him for the assailant.

The plan for the concerts was unveiled in Egyptian newspapers as a Dresden court, the same one where the murder was committed, started the trial of Wiens amid heavy security. Prosecutors are demanding the maximum sentence, life in prison.

Officials at both the Cairo Opera House and the German Embassy in Egypt declined to comment on the cancellation of the concerts. Egyptian sources, however, said that the move was prompted by rising public opposition to the event and concerns about potential attacks on the German musicians.

BM

Share this:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Diigo
  • Reddit
  • Google Bookmarks
  • RSS
  • Print
Email this: Email This
Tags: , , , , , , ,

5 comments
Leave a comment »

  1. [...] This post was Twitted by dresden_live [...]

  2. there’s no good reason behind cancelling the orchestra from playing. its just music being played by people from the same country where a girl was killed. was she stabbed with a flute? or maybe a trombone? was that same music playing in the mans ipod as he stabbed her? the 2 are completely unrelated.. like fish and ice cream.
    on one hand is culture, a group formed 500 yrs ago! to maintain PEACE and good relations. hello? on the other, one neo-nazi who is non representative of the entire country acting on his personal belief. what does an orchestra have anything to do with it? farouk hosni caved in because unfortunately in egypt its more important to do the popular thing than to do the logical thing.. also because he’s… well, he’s farouk hothni! think about it!
    still she was murdered because someone was pissed off that she won a lot of his money in a case against him. its a random act of anger. not related in any way to music, dresden orchestra, or islam vs. germany. what is the point of blowing it up? i mean how many people were actually going to go see them at the opera aslan? 300? 400? now they’re pissed off. hope they dont end up going after marwa’s parents for revenge.

  3. One man, acting alone, commits a crime against an Egyptian and therefore vengeance must be taken against an entire nation?

    Would these same people find violence against themselves to be justified if an egyptian man had murdered a german woman?

  4. i agreewith you, ED. this is exaggerating and myself, i have had enough of this.
    they even called her ” martyr of hijab” .

  5. [...] see bikyamasr [...]

Leave Comment